min read

Testimonial vs Review: Strategies for Building Trust, Loyalty, and Brand Reputation through customer testimonial and reviews

Published on
June 19, 2024

Table of contents

How often do you deliberately go to the review section to test the reliability of a product or were compelled to purchase by heartfelt testimonials?

Testimonials and reviews are the most direct ways by which customers can communicate with the company and the rest of the customer community and provide feedback and honest experience stories. 

Now, testimonial vs. review is a common debate among marketers. However, testimonials and reviews both matter a lot in influencing customer decisions. Therefore, understanding the difference is essential for building good credibility so you can leverage both whenever needed in the best way possible. 

Customer feedback is also essential for the company to improve its products/services, packaging, branding, and other aspects. So, let’s start with discussing what reviews and testimonials are. 

Understanding the Difference: Review vs Testimonial 

What are Customer Testimonials?

Testimonials are detailed statements or endorsements from individuals who have experienced a product, service, or content. They often highlight personal experiences or benefits gained.

They can be in the form of a written description, video, audio, or any medium. Hence, testimonials can be more emotional, descriptive, and longer, and they can build a deeper connection with people. 

Source: Songflinch

Testimonials Pros

  • Storytelling Element - Testimonials are often more personal and emotional, allowing businesses to convey a narrative about their product or service and its benefits. They give you immense scope for branding through storytelling and drive customer trust. 
  • Positive Endorsement - These are typically positive accounts, which can help promote the strengths of a product or service and build a brand reputation.
  • Deeper Emotional Appeal - Testimonials have a greater scope of leaving a deeper mark on the viewer/reader as compared to reviews. 

Testimonials Cons

  • Lack of Balance - Since testimonials are mostly solicited and positive, they may not portray a balanced representation of customer experiences.
  • Limited Constructive Feedback - They usually don't provide specific or constructive feedback that could help a business improve its offerings.
  • Skepticism - Potential customers may be skeptical of testimonials as they're usually curated by the company.

What are Reviews?

Reviews are opinions or evaluations shared by individuals regarding a product, service, or experience. They might not delve deeply into personal experiences but offer an overall assessment or critique/appreciation. Well-written customer reviews can make or break your brand and online reputation!

They can also include recommendations/suggestions based on their experience! In some cases, the reviewer may require a certain degree of expertise! For example, reviews written by health and medical professionals about a health product are more trusted than those of an average customer. 

So reviews are supposed to be more technical, factual, and objective, as compared to testimonials, which are more experience-based. 

For example, check out the following review on Zomato.  

Source: Zomato

Reviews Pros

  • Objectivity - Reviews often offer a more objective and comprehensive evaluation of a product or service, including both positive and negative aspects.
  • Improvements - They provide businesses with direct customer feedback, helping them identify areas of improvement.
  • Consumer Decision-Making - Potential customers often rely on product or service reviews to make informed purchasing decisions.

Reviews Cons

  • Negative Impact - One poor review can deter potential customers, impacting a business's image and sales.
  • Authenticity Issues - The authenticity of reviews can sometimes be questionable, with concerns over fake negative or positive reviews.
  • Management - It takes significant effort and resources to adequately manage and respond to reviews, especially negative ones.

Definition and Purpose

Fundamentally, customer reviews, testimonials, and all forms of feedback can differ in depth and purpose. Testimonials stress the benefits and attractions, but reviews can go further in reflecting people's experiences of all shades, positive and negative.

Testimonials are detailed, precise accounts, often with personal reference to one's experience of directly benefiting from a product or service. They are personal recommendations, highlighting only the positive.

However, reviews offer opinions or evaluations without necessarily exploring personal experiences. They are an overall appraisal or evaluation of a product, service, or experience: one can be either positive, negative, neutral and so on.

Format and Presentation and Usage in Marketing

Testimonials are typically presented as quotes, narratives, or anecdotes from contented customers, designed to highlight a positive experience with a product or service.

These firsthand accounts often come accompanied by a photograph or video of the customer to personalize the message and build authenticity. You can also use testimonial scripts or templates to make the process easier. 

Businesses frequently display these testimonials on their website or promotional materials, using compelling storytelling to relate with prospective customers on an emotional level.

For example, consider the following testimonial by a student at Cambridge. 

Source: Cambridge School

On the other hand, reviews are more publicly accessible and posted by consumers directly onto review sites, social media platforms, or a business's website. They often feature a rating system, usually out of five stars, along with a written description detailing the customer's experience. 

Review sites commonly organize these reviews in chronological order or sort based on their utility, allowing potential customers to read the most relevant feedback. This format promotes transparency, providing a more comprehensive view of the positive and negative aspects of a product or service to guide consumer purchasing decisions.

The following image shows these reviews of a Trustpilot integration plugin along with the respective ratings of the reviewers. As you can see, the presentation is quite different. 

Source: WordPress

Impact on Business

Why testimonials are important is mainly because of their significant role in establishing trust and credibility for your website or brand. Due to their nature, they are often perceived as sincere endorsements from actual clients, revealing positive experiences. 

Having testimonials on a business's platforms can thus effectively sway potential patrons towards choosing a product or service, bolstered by the assurances from satisfied customers.

Conversely, reviews supply essential feedback allowing for product or service enhancement. While their candidness and transparency can assure potential customers, they may not necessarily have the same persuasive power as testimonials in converting prospects. 

Reviews include both positive and negative feedback, and if a business has a mix of ratings, it may affect the persuasiveness of reviews to new customers.

Testimonials, reviews, or any other kind of feedback can be hard to collect, manage, and display, and may require a lot of time. However, there are tools like Testimonial Donut, which have a great interface and dashboard for collecting and managing testimonials easily. 

Whether you’re collecting a video testimonial or a review on Google, Testimonial Donut makes your job way easier and also lets you easily integrate them on your website. 

Strategies for Building Trust, Loyalty, and Brand Reputation: The Psychology Behind Testimonials and Reviews

Both reviews and testimonials aim at different aspects of consumer psychology and build trust and social proofing in individuals in different ways. 

Leveraging Reviews for Reputation Management

So consider this! As a consumer, when you see negative reviews along with positive reviews, what’s your first response? You want to dive deeper into the reviews and see if the product will work for you or not! 

Most customers, when they spot negative reviews, tend to go through them first! However, whether you’re going through positive reviews or negative ones, the point is that you are indulged in the product and are considering it!

That’s because negative reviews imply authenticity and transparency and build trust. So, it’s always good to have a mix of negative and positive reviews as they build social-proofing of more customers using the product/service! 

Source: Songlinch/Trustpilot

Building Trust with Testimonials

Testimonials serve a different purpose! These tend to highlight positive experiences and benefits, lending a feeling of dependability. Success stories or positive outcomes create an emotional connection, fostering trust built on relatability and success!

Once a customer is even half-interested in a product/service, you want to sell them a narrative of how their life will be when they buy your product/service, which is best done through Testimonials! 

Influencing Decision-making with Reviews

Reviews provide a comprehensive evaluation, allowing consumers to assess various perspectives before making a decision. Negative reviews offer insights into potential drawbacks, enabling more informed choices. 

Positive reviews, on the other hand, affirm the product's value, influencing the decision positively. That way, negative reviews will filter out the customers who may not benefit from your products and services and will bring the consumers who are your core audience and will tend to repeat! 

Influencing Decision-making with Testimonials

Personal stories and positive accounts create an emotional appeal, impacting the decision-making process significantly. They resonate more on an emotional level, influencing consumers' decisions based on relatability and the perceived success of others.

Again, testimonials sell a story of experience and change and reaffirm their consideration, turning it into choice!  

Building Brand Image

Both reviews and testimonies shape the brand image of your product/service, giving potential customers an idea of the perception of the company! This is not just about this particular product/service but also about the long-term relationship your client/customers have with you. 

It’s about how they perceive your products and how they will talk about them in public! Consider this. The person who adds the review and testimonial is also extremely important!

For example, a mother feeding their newborn Cerelac would like to see reviews and testimonials from another mother! 

Source: Amazon

In this case, reviews and testimonials act like approval. Next, it’s also important if they connect with the mother, adding the review, like which language they speak, how old they are, etc. 

Engagement and Interaction

Testimonials and reviews display that people are interested in and discussing the product. Reviews, especially when brands engage with them by addressing concerns or appreciating positive feedback, foster a sense of involvement. 

You must have seen how companies address negative reviews, ask for feedback, and even compensate customers for a bad experience. That simply shows that the company cares about the customers. 

Similarly, testimonials that acknowledge and highlight customer experiences can deepen engagement and loyalty. 

Enhancing Customer Loyalty with Testimonials and Reviews

Once you interact with a customer in a meaningful way, whether you’re addressing their feedback or collecting their review, you indulge in a more long-term relationship with them. 

So, consider the journey of a customer that starts with discovering the product, making their choice by going through reviews/testimonials, buying it, using it, and so on. In between thai if you reach out to them for feedback, that just makes the relationship deeper. 

If the customer also makes the effort to post a review about the product/service or repeats the order, these are just additional layers that further foster their loyalty. Any positive experience with the product may turn them into brand advocates leading to organic and positive word of mouth or endorsement. 

Strategies for Collecting Testimonials and Reviews

Collecting customer feedback in the form of testimonials and reviews is crucial for business growth and development. Here are some strategic methods to encourage customers to share their experiences:

Offering Incentives

An effective way of encouraging customers to leave feedback is by offering them incentives. This could be a discount on their next purchase, a gift, or entry into a prize draw. The prospect of receiving something in return can motivate customers to take the time to write a review or testimonial.

Automated Review Requests

Automating review requests can streamline the collection of customer feedback. You can achieve this by sending follow-up emails or messages after a purchase or service experience, inviting customers to share their opinions. Automation ensures that you can send these requests promptly and consistently, thereby enhancing the likelihood of receiving valuable feedback.

Exceptional Customer Service

Providing stellar customer service can inspire customers to share their positive experiences. When customers feel valued and satisfied, they're more likely to express their feelings in the form of reviews or testimonials. 

This involves timely responses, resolving issues effectively, and going above and beyond to meet customer needs. Towards collecting testimonials and reviews, it's crucial to maintain authenticity and transparency. 

Customers value honest feedback and can usually discern when reviews or testimonials have been altered or falsely represented. Hence, it's key to ensure that reviews and testimonials are displayed as they are, representing a true reflection of customer experiences. 

You must also respond promptly and respectfully to both positive and negative feedback as that demonstrates a business's commitment to enhancing customer satisfaction.

You can start right away with this journey, by using Testimonial Donut which lets you collect testimonials/reviews with ease and also manage them in its dashboard which is quite user-friendly and well-organized. You can integrate these reviews and testimonials on your website, social media posts, etc. 

Ways to Integrate Testimonials and Reviews in Your Marketing

Unified Display Platforms

  • Website Integration: Showcase curated testimonials and reviews prominently on the website! Also, show any prominent or popular clients you have had that can build credibility.
Source: GrowLetter
  • Landing Pages: Use testimonials strategically on landing pages to reassure potential customers and encourage action. You can use services like Testimonial Donut to easily aggregate testimonials on your landing pages. 

Social Proof and Influence

  • Social Media Promotion: Share positive reviews and testimonials across social media platforms to leverage social proof and influence purchasing decisions.
  • User-Generated Content: Encourage customers to share experiences on social media, creating user-generated content that amplifies positive sentiment.

Content Marketing

  • Case Studies: Develop case studies using detailed testimonials to illustrate success stories, demonstrating real-world applications and benefits.
  • Blog Posts and Articles: Create content around customer experiences, featuring testimonials to add authenticity and relevance to topics.

Email Marketing

  • Customer Stories in Newsletters: Incorporate snippets of testimonials or success stories in newsletters to engage subscribers and reinforce brand trust.
  • Review Request Emails: Encourage customers to leave reviews or provide testimonials through targeted email campaigns.

Paid Advertising

  • Ad Extensions: Utilize reviews as ad extensions in paid search campaigns to enhance ad credibility and click-through rates.
  • Video Testimonials in Ads: Incorporate video testimonials in digital ads for a more engaging and impactful marketing approach.

Final Thoughts

Testimonials and reviews serve various purposes, and both are important for building your brand and trust. Quickly summarising Testimonial vs Review: while reviews are great for short, factual, and objective information, testimonials are more detailed and can appeal more emotionally. 

In the competitive world of e-commerce and online business, you need both so you can give customers a fair chance to make an informed decision and also give your products/service a fair chance to be exposed to customers and even stand out amongst all the choices. 

Since collecting testimonials and reviews can be quite a tedious job that you may not have the time or bandwidth for, you can also try Testimonial Donut, which makes the entire process easier for you! Our product can also aggregate your reviews from sites like Google reviews and allow you to showcase them on your website alongside testimonials collected via Testimonial Donut.


Add testimonials to you website for free

Collect, manage, share all your testimonials & Google reviews in one place. All 100% free. So bloody easy your gran can do it!

Take a look at Testimonial Donut
Subscribe to the newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every week.

Get started